…What a fascinating modern age we live in. – J. Aubrey
Boing Boing

A friend sent me a link about this new bicycle wheel. He offered it “without endorsement or commentary,” knowing I would more than likely make comments about it. The loopwheel replaces spokes with springs. Springs made of carbon fiber.
Interesting concept,except for the obvious drawbacks:
- made from expensive carbon fiber. Haven’t seen a price point for these yet but I can almost guarantee it will be well above a standard aluminum rim, steel spoke and hub wheel.
- not repairable. Well, actually there are methods for repairing carbon fiber, but highly unlikely these methods will apply t springs.
- failure modes. Spoked wheels tend to fail gracefully. Well except for the spectacular folding failure of front racing wheels with stupidly low spoke counts and radial lacing. How will these spring wheels fail when the carbon fiber goes crack!!?
- inefficient. Significant power will be lost to the springs when pedaling. The wheel will flex more than spoked wheel and absorb a lot of power.
- unstable. What dampens the oscillation inherent in spring systems?
- throwaway. Aluminum and steel have mature recycle and reuse streams. To my knowledge, carbon fiber cannot be efficiently recycled.
Meet George Jetson
And then there is the never ending question of when do we get our flying cars? Apparently, feasibility studies are underway. Once again we see people trying to invent and build something because they can without asking the question of whether they should.
Set aside that the idea that this will be horribly expensive to buy and maintain. Ignore the glaring issue that this is a solution looking for a problem. Are we really going to sanction this insanity? Far too many motorists can’t even control a vehicle in two dimensions, let alone three. What will the mishap rate be for these?
Here’s a hint. General aviation (private airplanes) has the highest mishap rate of any segment, including very risky military aircraft. The leading cause of crashes of small aircraft is engine failure due to fuel starvation. Yes, private pilots run out of fuel. It happens all the time. And these are people who get far more training and scrutiny than your average joe driving a car.
How will these vehicles interact with the surface transportation system? Will they be required to land at an airport and then transition to car mode? Or will be eventually allow takeoffs and landings direction on our highways? Who certifies the operators?
Progress? Not too sure.
Like this:
Like Loading...